Monday, June 6, 2022

The History of Whitefish Point

 


Whitefish Point has been known to explorers, missionaries, Native Americans and sailors for hundreds of years.  Because of the vast fishing opportunities provided by Lake Superior, the Chippewa tribal people used Whitefish Point as a meeting place.  This area was known as the land of Gitchee Gummee, which Henry Wadsworth Longfellow derived the song of “Hiawatha.”  The Whitefish Point area is full of natural splendor and marks the turning point for all shipping travel leaving and coming into Lake Superior.  Valuable copper and iron ore deposits were discovered in the region.  The economic opportunities brought commercial traffic to the region.  During the early 1800s there were no lighthouses, no charts, no harbors, no weather reports, nothing to provide assistance to mariners concerning the rugged conditions of the shorelines and storms. 

By 1846, the 80 miles coastline from Whitefish Point to Munising, Michigan earned the ill-omened label “The Shipwreck Coast of Lake Superior.”  There was an alarming amount of maritime disasters along this 80 mile stretch.  At the west end of the shipwreck coast hosts pictured rocks which are void of harbors or places where large vessels can find solace from the harsh northwest winds.  The deep, open waters of Lake Superior can become treacherous with a moment’s notice and has forced the mariners toward their doom in deadly waves along the jagged and deserted coastline.  The U.S. Lifesaving Service was established in 1876 to serve the Great Lakes surrounding Michigan. 

It was recognized by Congress that a lighthouse was necessary for Whitefish Point; however, Congress was bogged down by the haggling over the expense of this venture. Horace Greeley visited the Lake Superior area in 1847 and due to his notoriety as a renowned New York publisher, he brought attention to the danger and wrote a series of editorials criticizing the U.S. Congress for delaying construction to aid in navigation.  His efforts proved to be successful.   Congress appropriated $5000 for the construction of the first lighthouse which was constructed by Ebenezer Warner from Sandusky, Ohio. 

The first lighthouse was constructed in 1849, it was a simple stone tower which was proved to be unsuitable for the extreme wind and other stormy conditions.  James VanRenselaer was the first lighthouse keeper.  He served from October 1848 until May 1851. Was he hired before the lighthouse was constructed and did he assist with the construction the lighthouse? The first lanterns burned sperm whale oil and could be seen for 17 miles.

The waters of the Lake Superior flowed into Lake Huron and Lake Michigan via the St. Marys River which named after Pere Marquette during his exploration.  Father Marquette named the St. Marys Rapids “Le Sault de Sainte Marie” and this led to the birth of the cities of Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan and Ontario.  Before 1855, every shipping vessel entering or leaving Lake Superior had to be portaged and physically taken out of the water and dragged on land around the rapids at Sault Ste. Marie.  Under the guidance of Charles T. Harvey, the first lock of the St. Marys Falls Canal was opened, which created a new enhanced form of maritime trade for the Upper Great Lakes. 

In 1861, due to the transport of iron ore which was important to the defense of the Union, President Lincoln authorized funding for a new “iron-pile” lighthouse structure still being utilized today.  President Lincoln realized that War Between the States was unavoidable.   He was concerned with preserving the flow of resources for its defense.  Identical lighthouses were built at DeTour and Manitou Island.  The light keeper’s dwelling was constructed with an unusual covered bridge from the living quarters to the base of the spiral stairway inside the cylindrical tower.  Due to the heavy fog in the area, fog horns were installed. 

Between 1848 until 1883, there were ten different lightkeepers and their families served at Whitefish Point.  With the appointment of Charles Kimball, who served for 20 years and the high turnover rate was ceased.  Robert Carlson served from 1903 to 1931.  One of the main responsibilities of the keeper was to haul to the lamp at the lighthouse cans of fuel from the oil storage house.  This storage facility had to be one hundred feet from the lighthouse in case of fire. 

Today,the site of  Michigan’s most famous lighthouse hosts many interesting sites to visit.  The original barracks that housed the Carlson family is replicated and preserved for the multitude of tourists that visit the site.  A human figure sculpture of Robert Carlson can be seen sitting at an antique desk completing his duties.  At another building a presentation about the sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald can be viewed.  The main museum contains artifacts describing the history of Whitefish Point including information about various shipwrecks.  A preserved 17 foot tall Second Order Fresnel lens from White Shoal s is located in the center of this museum. In another building three are displays depicting the history of the U.S. Lifesaving Service.  Whitefish Point has been known and explored for centuries by many people. 

 

Power and Control Through Patriarchal Domination and the Church

 


Throughout history all paths to “the divine” were not respected and honored. Indian traditional spiritual practices, Indian legends, Buddhism, Christianity, and other forms of religion and spirituality consist of a vast amount of valuable lessons to be learned. Wise women and men from all races could lead the way to salvation and unlock the secrets to a life of contentment.  The power of prayer has been known to provide healing and a feeling of comfort along with a connection to the universe. Perceived superiority instilled by rigid religious belief systems caused a vast number of people to suffer.

Feelings of superiority breeds violence. The state of many Native Americans concerning poverty, domestic violence and other serious challenges is the result of a lack of spirituality in their lives. The Church and others in authority have wielded discrimination against women, setting most of the world off balance for thousands of years by the lack of matriarchal support and guidance. While certain aspects of religion have their place, oftentimes most religions do not support a strong spiritual relationship with divinity on a daily basis.   

Today, the unquestioning acceptance of modernization has deterred many from seeing divinity as a significant part of the modern world. All human societies have manifested a belief system that explains the story of their creation, and phenomenon such as floods and other catastrophes.  Many of the stories portrayed in the Koran, Bible and Indian legends for example consist of moral teachings and the actions of divinity serving as important performers in unforgettable events throughout history. Many people are too busy to stop and learn from these valuable resources.

Upon careful scrutiny, it was proven that Noah’s flood could not have happened as reported in the Bible.  Geological factors based on the discovery of animal skeletons do not support the Noah’s ark happenings.  Controversy about the age of this earth and other scientific data has revealed that this planet may have had a very different past.  Doubts about a belief system based on a book, the Bible, has shaken the religious and spiritual foundation for a multitude of people and left them without a source of spirituality.

Patriarchal domination has wielded power and control over the masses as far back as early Greek civilization. One of the most flagrant examples of this is evident in the Church, meaning primarily the Roman Catholic Church. The Church either served as the sole ruler over the masses, or worked with the ruling class to provide governance during the time of the Roman Empire and after the collapse of the Roman Empire.

Interpretations of biblical messages served as the catalyst for oppression, and are linked to the historical trauma for Indian people and other subjugated people of many races, especially women. Bloody skirmishes between opposing factions and acts of oppression have scarred many in the name of God and religion. A multitude of Indian people were forced to accept Christianity and abandon their traditional spiritual practices.  However, it is essential as a part of being fully human to have the freedom to decide one’s own moral standards.  Freedom does not represent the absence of restrictions, it means finding the most liberating limitations.

David Marshall in his book The Truth about Jesus and the Lost Gospels makes reference to Christianity as the most liberating form of religion.  He refers to stop lights and stopping at these lights, which can be proven to be liberating as opposed to traffic jams. Rules are needed otherwise there will be chaos according to Marshall. However, traditional spiritual practices provided the freedom for Indian people to seek their own relationship with the divine, a form of spirituality that lent itself to guidance and support for Indian youth embarking on their spiritual journeys.  These Indian youth were instructed on what to do, such as participating in vision quests, and analyzing their dreams, not what to think. 

Traditional spiritual leaders emerged thousands of years ago from small communal tribes as individuals who could explain mystical phenomena and offer ways to resolve problems. These explanations helped alleviate fear, sustain focus on cooperative efforts to accomplish tasks essential for survival, and maintain cohesion among everyone residing in those small villages.  If one was to oppose the cultural values of their tribe, they would risk alienating themselves.  Isolation most likely would result in death.  Leaders were selected and earned the right to lead the village because of their acts of wisdom, kindness, bravery, and their concern for the well-being of the entire village. 

On the other hand, the hierarchy that evolved within church leadership created a ‘top-down’ mentality placing lay members at the bottom.  Members were taught to believe they had to go through the priests to have a connection with the divine.  Today, many Christian people often believe they possess the absolute truth, and everyone would be better served if they adopted their form of truth.  This belief in their form of absolute truth endangers everyone’s freedom.  As a result of this narrow-mindedness, Churches have remained stagnant, and the following statements hold true for many of these religious institutions.

·         Church is patriarchal: there’s no room for full participation of women.

·         Church is authoritarian: it attempts and oftentimes succeeds to enslave its members by deciding what they must believe and practice in every situation.

·         Church is intolerant of other viewpoints.  Individuals with different viewpoints are considered unsaved.[i]

Indian people did not fight over religion, and their form of spirituality was of a personal nature with the Great Mystery.  Spirituality is the essence of one’s soul, an individual’s innermost nature, and represents the synergy in all things, animate and inanimate. Spirituality does not only represent tolerance and acceptance, it is the feeling of universal oneness and unity in diversity.   It refers to a general sensitivity to moral, ethical, compassionate, and existential issues without reference to any religious doctrine.  Spirituality is larger than religion, it includes an awareness of the connectedness of all that is, and accepts that all of life has meaning and purpose and is accordingly blessed.  It could be defined as the animating force in life, symbolized by breath, wind, vigor, and courage and can be considered an active and passive process.  Spirituality is inborn and exclusive to all people, and represents a tendency to move towards knowledge, love, meaning, hope, transcendence, connectedness, and compassion. [ii]   

Before the onset of the European influence in this country, children were raised with traditional teachings to bolster their awareness of their personal spiritual journeys.  These lessons consisted of what would become a way of life for them.  These lessons included:

·         “respect for all life forms and further sacred space

·         love and honor for the Sacred Self

·         responsibility of each individual for their spirituality, their own voice, and direction in life

·         seeking and following a personal vision or purpose

·         honoring various transitions in life: puberty rites, rites of passage, becoming an elder, etc.

·         living in the present moment, learning to manage fear

·         each person has a right to make choices about their various journeys

·         every journey has value, and all visions are to be honored

·         all experiences of life have lessons for us to learn

·         we learn from both daytime and nighttime experiences

·         there are no mistakes in life

·         spirit guides and Elders are available to provide advice and guidance, but the choice belongs to the individual

·         everyone can honor the child and the Elder growing within

·         the Creator gives us messages and signs to guide us

·         as we learn more about ourselves (our gifts and limitations), we're more able to practice self-discipline and maintain personal integrity

·         like the bear, we must sometimes enter the cave of inner awareness in order to know ourselves better, find joy in the silence, and seek our own honey of truth

·         healing means knowing and balancing oneself

·         the beauty of life is in all directions

·         life can be enjoyed fully, and personal power is strengthened when there is no guilt or self blame

·         we are always connected and related to the universe” [iii]

Conversely, religion is generally associated with a body of people adhering to a particular set of beliefs, practices, rituals and theory, and provides guidance for moral behaviors and can be limiting in focus. 

The commonalities of most religions are:

·         All major religions basically teach the same things about moral and good behaviors and explain the rationale behind evil circumstances.

·         Each religion only sees a portion of the truth, not the whole truth.

·         Religious belief is culturally and historically biased.

According to Traditionalists and others who support the practice of meaningful spirituality, individuals don’t have to be in elaborate churches to pray.  The term “Traditionalists” was developed to refer to those who believe in what was considered pagan values including those practiced by traditional Indian people.  The term, “God,” “divinity,”  “the divine,” and the “Creator” will be used from this point forward to define the higher being in order to be all-inclusive. Each form of religion and spirituality celebrates some higher being, and these terms appear to be the most widely used in this country.

Progress comes with many losses. Today, spirituality isn’t considered real by many people.  More and more people are concerned with the process of production and its association with monetary goals. Competition for “bigger and better” as well as the separation associated with competition has led to alienation.  Technological advances are being developed at an astonishing pace, but rather than giving people more control of their lives, technology seems to be taking it away. As a result, what exists is an unhealthy level of dysfunction in most relationships, and direct person-to-person communication has been replaced by various types of technology. 

            Fear and ignorance has also served as a catalyst for deterring people from establishing and/or forming trust and healing.  Ignorance and fear prevents the seeking of positive growth and change. Two major fears continue to be perpetuated: not being enough, and not having enough. A paradigm shift has occurred for millions of people who have deserted traditional religions and replaced these conceptual formats with materialism. The fear of “not having enough” fostered the greed of many religious leaders and rulers thousands of years ago, creating many of the difficulties existing today.  These difficulties include the lack of community cohesiveness and an overall dissatisfaction with one’s life.  Religion came into existence to control the masses.  Patriarchal domination was another way in which power was utilized to govern those considered weaker and oftentimes threatening. 

Some people believe biblical patriarchy does not mean that man is dominant.  It means man is to serve as head of his household as a provider and protector, and to love his household as our higher being loves all of creation; he should be willing to give his life for his family. Biblical patriarchy does not mean suppression of woman; quite the opposite.  Both men and women were meant to be on a spiritual path together living out their lives as patriarchs and matriarchs in equality. The rigidity and control put forth by patriarchal domination has corroded religious practices, and rendered it meaningless and lifeless in many ways.  All roles including leadership positions need to take on the matriarchal and patriarchal mindsets, which will help restore balance in the world.

            Matthew Fox, in his book The Coming of the Cosmic Christ, proposes that civilization as it is known today has been forced to succumb to patriarchal domination and has put people out of touch with the core meaning behind Christianity.  A very important component has been missing, which is the addition of the matriarchal mindset. The matriarchal mindset involves creativity and emotion, the nurturing elements necessary for any meaningful relationship.  The patriarchal mindset represents the linear mode of thinking based on intellect.  Intellect requires the balance creativity and an emotional standpoint can bring to the table.  Without the feminine aspect, what remains can be cold and unyielding.

Fox makes the statement that Indian people had it right from the very beginning. They had a closer connection to their higher being, and spirituality was more meaningful for them.  Their higher power, the Creator, communicated often with them through dreams, vision quests, sweat lodge ceremonies, and other traditional spiritual practices.  Fox posed the question about the current existence of problems, such as drugs, alcohol and entertainment addictions, perhaps resulting from feelings of emptiness due to the lack of connection to the divine.[iv]

When something is feared and enhances insecurities, the abolishment of the fear causing elements becomes probable. The spiritual practices of the Indian people were outlawed until the 1970s. The mystery of these ceremonies led to feelings of fear for the Euro-Americans.  During this prohibition period, harmful sanctions were put into place to punish any Indian person who disobeyed and participated in traditional spiritual practices.  Many Indian people secretly continued their spiritual practices. Others felt they had no choice, but to adopt Christian religious beliefs. 

Concerning traditional spiritual practices, the spirit must come first and be nurtured in a way that creates a permeable wall for the divine to breach.  Traditionalism involves a partnership with oneself.  When things are in need of improvement, the solution is inside the individual’s mind, soul and heart.  Traditionalists believe everyone has everything they need inside of them to secure a relationship with the divine and to heal oneself in the following areas: spiritual, physical, emotional, and intellectual.  Today, many Indian people are feeling a loss because they do not have a connection to the divine. 

The Roman Empire’s expansion covered most of present day Europe and the Mediterranean area. The Roman Empire was in control of this land base and its resources before the appointment of Julius Caesar in 44BC until 1453, when the Ottoman Turks (Muslims) took over Constantinople. The size of the empire and its lengthy existence led to Roman influence on language, religion, architecture, philosophy, law and government of countries around the world to this day.

The Roman Emperors controlled the religious institutions and participated in the imperial cult system, which consisted of deceased emperors serving as demigods to be worshipped by all.  Their successors would appoint demigods to enhance their own status.  People have worshipped the Pope as if he were a deity.  When false gods are worshipped, it was and continues to be easy to convert and covet “things” and these things such as gold begin serving as false gods. God, Jesus, and other higher powers become less and less real. [v]

The Roman Catholic Church did everything in its power to sequester and control all pagan sacred documents. In 1945 an Arab peasant, named Mohammed Ali, found a whole library of Gnostic gospels hidden in a cave near Nag Hammadi in Upper Egypt on the bend of the Nile River.  He uncovered a three foot tall red jar that contained 12 papyrus books bound in leather and additional book stuffed inside another.  The books were written in an Egyptian language called Coptic, letters based on the Greek alphabet. These documents included the teachings of Christ and his disciples and speculations were made that they were written by Jesus’ first disciples. The authors of these documents were followers of an ancient group called Gnostics. [vi] Gnostics were considered mystics and progressive thinkers for that time period, which went against the Roman Catholic Church hierarchy.  Throughout history, other groups who went against the Church were punished for their beliefs.

The Gnostics existed before and during the onset of Christianity.  The word “Gnostic” was derived from the word “Gnosis” meaning knowledge of God.  Marshall in the book The Truth about Jesus and the Lost Gospels claimed that Gnosticism can be described as “salvation by knowledge.”  Marshall referred to knowledge of the self being the means to freedom according to Gnosticism.[vii] The Gnostics were considered outrageous and even dangerous by the Roman Catholic Church.  They did not support the idea that those who were seeking a relationship with their higher power had to do so with the aid of a priest. Their beliefs were based on a mystic knowledge and did not fit with the monetary and political wishes of the Church.

However, the publicity the Roman Catholic Church gave the Gnostics served only to feed the interests of many of the inhabitants of the Roman Empire. The Roman Catholic Church took their own interpretation of the Jesus story as a literal account of historical events, and thus they were referred to as Literalists.  The Gnostics were imprisoned and/or put to death because they went against the beliefs of the Church. Another historical reason the Gnostics were obliterated was because some of the Gnostic divinities were female. [viii]

One of the beliefs of the Gnostics involved their conviction that Eve was a courageous woman. As a result of Eve’s acceptance of the apple, she moved humans closer to the attainment of many divine gifts. The eating of the apple represented the obtainment of knowledge. The false perception promoted by the Church was Eve was weak and brought her own bad luck by coercing Adam to partake in the eating of the apple delivered by Satan.  Myths can have great power.

Because of the impact of this creation story, women have had to endure a great deal of blame, shame and have been associated with darkness and evil. The story in Genesis, the first book of the Bible, with God’s six-day creation, and inception of Adam and Eve portrayed God as tyrannical and trivial. Nakedness associated with sexual sin, female vulnerability and God’s wrath were paramount in the message derived from this story. [ix] The concept of a vengeful God has also caused a separation between people and God. 

Another belief of the Gnostics was reincarnation, which was vehemently denounced by the Church.  Reincarnation was a belief also supported by Jesus. According to various written works, Jesus also propagated the term karma.  Part of the lost teachings of Jesus involves karma, and making the right choices.  People determine their own destinies. It is also a part of free will.  If people do awful things to others, bad karma will knock at the doors of these individuals. These terrible things usually happen if people do not take responsibility for their actions and/or do not see their harmful actions as wrong. [x] Indian people coined the term “red road.”  One must do good things for all or one has fallen off the “red road.”  Falling off the right path can lead to bad things happening during the course of one’s lifetime.

What would be the purpose of denouncing the concepts of reincarnation and karma?  If someone was considered saved by accepting Christ as their savior at the 11th hour, a need did not exist to take full responsibility for one’s actions and all individuals could be accepted into the kingdom of God no matter how horrible their actions. Were these beliefs propagated by the priests and others in power embraced and enforced to excuse their personal wrongdoings?

The Quakers, originally from England, came to the new world during the mid 1650s.  Similarities existed between the spiritual practices of the Quakers and the Indian people.  One of their beliefs purported that one did not have to be in a church to establish fellowship with others and the divine.  Everyone has the light within them. Also, people who were repelled by the rules and rituals of religion discovered the Quaker views were more refreshing for the times.  It was their philosophy that they had a responsibility to become friends with people of all races. The Quakers were known to be very respectful of the Indian people. They worked alongside the Indian people and did not try to change their form of spirituality. 

In 1681, William Penn met with the Indians under the great elm of Shackamason and made friends with the Indians.  Trees often serve as sacred meeting places for Indian people. Robert Hodgson, a Quaker missionary, was arrested, imprisoned and treated harshly because he was drawing a large crowd at his meetings. [xi] The Quakers, Indian people and other groups such as the Gnostics were persecuted for their spiritual practices and beliefs because their beliefs differed from those who were self acclaimed Christians.

Despair relates to sin because it sets people up to be taken over by evil doers.  Those with dark souls prey on individuals during their most vulnerable moments.  Many of the children who attended the boarding and residential schools, while their parents were left to reside on reservations and reserves, were very vulnerable and lived in a constant state of despair.  These children were often subjected to cruel and harsh treatment.  The dark souls who perpetuated the abuse were feeding off the spirits of these innocent children like parasites.  Much harm was caused to the children’s souls and their entire beings as a result of the sexual abuse committed by the priests, nuns, and others in authority.

Leon J. Podles described many scenes in which children were sexually abused at the hands of Catholic priests in his book entitled Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church. Only a portion of the sexual abuse was ever reported.  Because this crime was committed in private, it was difficult to determine the actual number of victims.  The number of alleged victims was 10,677 in the John Jay Report. This number was raised to 12,257 by later reports, and the number is most likely much higher than that; Podles estimated at least 100,000 children fell victim to these pedophiles. As mentioned earlier, a number of sexual abuse cases were never reported, which may have resulted because of the shame experienced by the victims.

            Podles noted that the individuals who perpetrated the sexual abuse on these naïve children can be labeled as narcissistic, and this label was not only reserved for abusive priests.  The diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder was given to the Catholic bishops as well, because these bishops worked diligently to cover up the wrongful acts of the priests. It was all about appearances and not about the harm caused to the children.

Podles also referred to these pedophiles as sociopathic. The priests were noted as having an indifferent conscience filled with apathy for the truth. They preached what they felt was the truth concerning the word of God and what best served their self serving wishes. Sadly, many of the staff members placed in charge of the boarding and residential school students did not differ from these reprehensible individuals. 

The abusive priests lacked the ability to assume social responsibility.  If wrongful acts were brought to their attention, it would elicit an attitude of nonchalance.  Although these narcissistic individuals were completely self-involved, they were skilled in the ways of social seduction, often with an air of dignity and confidence.  These abusive priests were skillful in enticing, coercing and tantalizing the needy and the naïve.

            Those pedophile priests also possessed a pathological sense of entitlement. During the period of time when this country was being settled, the Euro-Americans also felt they had the right to take over anything that came across their paths simply because they were white and European. People who exhibit narcissistic personality disorder characteristics also express grandiosity through their obsessions with fantasies of success. They are convinced they are unique and in turn require excessive admiration and adulation.  Several examples were given by Podles of occasions when pedophile priests would be given public recognition for their heroic acts of generosity and other forms of public service. At the same time, they were sexually abusing children. They were known to exploit others for their own ends, lack empathy for the feelings of others, could be envious of others, and were arrogant and became enraged when they felt frustrated or contradicted. They had to get their way.[xii]

            Attempts have been made to explain the existence of evil. It’s been somewhat impossible to reconcile that God is good; God is all-powerful; and that terrible things can happen to good people, especially children.  Christian Science correlates evil with an illusion of our mortal minds.  It doesn’t really exist.  Buddhism equates evil to the bad karma one has created in a past life, especially concerning acts like the rape of a young child.  That child must have carried to his or her current life a bad karma debt.  Christianity doesn’t offer any plausible explanation except that there is not an act so heinous that God cannot turn it into good.  Concerning the three prepositions mentioned above, such as God is all-powerful; all three cannot be reconciled in the case of specific situations.[xiii]  In turn, this dilemma has led many to challenge their faith when horrible things do happen. 

            Many of the boarding school employees mocked, belittled, and prohibited the Indian form of spirituality and denounced these ways as evil and savage. Moreover, if the children did not accept Christianity as it was forced upon them, they were told they would be doomed to hell.  Hell meant the devil, his pitchforks and extreme heat that could melt the skin off their bodies. Those in authority who condemned others to hell considered those who were condemned as being unequal and worthless. A forced form of religion drew these children in, gave them hope, and then damned them for their perceived sins while they were being abused over and over again. 

People who attended the Holy Childhood Boarding School reported they possessed a fear of the dark.  One individual stated he believed he may become evil and dark if he did not convert to Christianity. These children were told they would be thrown in a deep dark hole if they did not change their ways and become Christianized. They were taught to despise their families’ histories and that these histories had no value. Indian people working with the Aboriginal Healing Project in Canada referred to the losses of their culture that occurred at the residential schools as spiritual abuse.  They were forced to reject their native tribal languages, and obey only those in authority at the boarding and residential schools. Their only viable future was a “white” future.

Those in authority at the boarding and residential schools taught the children about a false God, one who was merciless and cruel. The fear of God propagated by the Church caused further separation between individuals and their higher beings. It is difficult to determine when the fear of God was initiated and instilled as a part of Christian practices. 

            The Church and others who assumed authority began a quest to dominate women and later people of color over 2000 years ago.  The Greek religion, from which much of Roman beliefs evolved, was one of dominance through acts of cruelty and barbarism, such as rapes of goddesses and mortal women.  The Roman Empire followed suit. Women were listed as property in the Old Testament of the Bible 11 times. Women were not given the right to vote until 1920 in the U.S. and were treated with cruelty, including imprisonment and forced feeding, when they marched to obtain that right. In current times, women continue to be portrayed in demeaning ways in the media as sex objects.

Jesus has been described as having the utmost respect for women and people of all races, and valued others’ opinions and leadership abilities.  He was open to learning about the various cultures.  Jesus was known to have traveled with 72 women at one point.  Mary of Magdalene was portrayed as a woman with seven devils and a woman with deep seated problems. She was referred to as a prostitute who washed the feet of Jesus with her tears and other disparaging accusations.[xiv] Other sources reveal that Jesus and Mary of Magdalene had a committed and intimate relationship and Mary was a gifted individual like Jesus and none of the derogatory descriptions applied.  Some sources portray Jesus as a rabbi, meaning teacher.  One of the most logical arguments for the relationship between Jesus and Mary was that Jesus would have been regarded with suspicion if he were not married.  Rabbis were required to be married.  Marshall referred to Jesus as a rabbi when he was describing events that led up to Jesus’ crucifixion. [xv]

            Because of these prejudices against women the theologians and scholars justified the Salem, Massachusetts witch trials that took place between 1692 and 1693.  However, witch trials had also occurred in Europe from the 1300s to the end of the 1600s.  Hundreds of thousands of people in Europe, predominantly women, were put to death.  Joan of Arc, an astounding woman who assisted France in armed combat during the Hundred Year Wars, was charged with witchcraft and burned at the stake. These lethal witch hunts happened for many reasons and multiple theories were established to explain this phenomenon.

·         The Church Oppression Theory involved the Church falsely inventing the concept of witches to eliminate opponents who threatened the Church’s credibility and to gain wealth. 

·         The Greed Theory implicated the elites in their quest to seize the property of others.

·         The mental health condition of the people involved in the hunts led to mass hysteria.  The peasants became neurotic and psychotic, and in a group panic went after individuals believed to be witches.

·         A Social Control Theory involved the desire to maintain control over the masses, and instill cultural uniformity.  Administrative officials linked specific individuals to a dangerous conspiracy involving witchcraft.

·         The Confessional Conflict Theory was associated with reformation and the conflict between the Protestants and Roman Catholics.  Each group used witchcraft as an excuse to attack one another.

·         The Pagan Religious Rebellion Theory is another reason why the witch hunts may have happened in Europe.  Ancient spiritual practices were blamed by the Christians for causing disasters such as plagues, famines, and storms.[xvi]

Approximately 200 people, again mainly women, were killed in Salem. They were accused of practicing the devil’s magic. The witch hunts occurred in Massachusetts as a result of a war that was started in 1689 by the English rulers William and Mary. The war of 1689 was fought against the French by the English and took place in the American colonies of upstate New York, Nova Scotia and Quebec. People in exile escaping the ravages of this war fled to the Salem area.  These additions to the population of this area put a strain on the resources of the original inhabitants.  Competition existed between the wealthy and the farmers over resources. The squabbling in the village was also considered the work of the devil.  To rid the village of evil, those individuals who were associated with witchery were put to death, again mainly women.

            Much speculation about these events occurred as a result of extensive modern studies. One of the theories associated with some recorded bizarre behaviors of accused individuals was linked to the fungus ergot found in rye, wheat and other cereal plants.  This fungus can cause muscle spasms, vomiting, delusions and hallucinations.  In later years, the colony came to the conclusion that those who were convicted were innocent and the colony compensated the families of those found guilty. [xvii] Although the witch hunts were terminated, discrimination against women continued.          

            Bishop John Selby Spong has attributed men’s antagonism towards women as being linked to a primal fear, the fear of blood, which has not been addressed. He made reference to five places in the Bible relating to women and blood during menstruation and child birth. The blood of women during these times was considered unclean.  Indian males also had a fear of blood because it was related to death.  They were puzzled how a woman could bleed for four days and still be alive.

Indian people considered women’s menstruation time a time when women were closest to the divine and were very powerful.  Indian women had to sleep and live separately from their husbands during their menstruation time because of their perceived powers.  They could not participate in ceremonies.  Menstruation was referred to as a cleansing time for women, which enhanced their status even further within tribal communities.  In the Bible it was stated there were restrictions placed on women as to when they could join others after childbirth or following menstruation. The period of time when women had to stay away from others was longer if a female child was born.

            Spong speculated that women were referred to as the weaker sex because of lack of bodily strength, their inability to protect their families as well as their male counterparts, and their vulnerability during the last month of pregnancy and while nursing. The connection mothers of newborns had with their offspring is associated with a form of weakness. The statement “women and children first” also depicts dependency.  The interpretation of the story in Genesis in which woman was created from man has paved the way for the idea that men are superior and women are subservient.[xviii]  During the earlier days when the Roman Empire was in full swing, many Roman women became Christians because of the protection it provided them. Christians were considered to have a higher status; thus, were not as readily killed.[xix] The Church has had a major influence on labels, definitions and role models of the underdogs in the modern world.

When listening to a tribal drum group, take notice of the higher pitched voices of the men when they begin singing and then how their voices became deeper for the latter portion of the song.  It was mentioned by an Indian singer and drummer that in order to seek balance; they celebrate their feminine side by singing in a higher voice for the first part of a song.  Indian people who have managed to return to some of the traditional practices and have the ability to live in two worlds have found more of a sense of balance.

A vast number of similarities exist between the ancient Hebrew beliefs and that of the Native Americans prior to the arrival of the Europeans.  According to ancient Hebrew beliefs, to practice Christianity in its true sense meant one needs to be modest, sensitive, loving, kind, empathetic and understanding, similar to the practices of traditional Indian people.  The entity of Satan did not exist with the early Hebrew beliefs.  Importance was placed on building a personal relationship with God independent from the community in which one resides.  Native Americans fostered this same belief with their children at an early age during the traditional period. 

The interpretation of dreams was encouraged.  Dreams symbolized the connection and communication between individuals and the Creator. Fasting and vision quests were another way in which Indian people would explore their relationship with the spirit world.  Fasting is also mentioned in the Bible as a way of communing with God.  Ancient Hebrew beliefs referred to sex as healthy, spiritual, and not sinful.[xx]  The union between man and woman, according to the beliefs of the Traditionalists, is not fraught with sin.  It is considered natural, and there is an expectation that it will lead to creating life’s most precious gift, children. 

            In the past, for those practicing their faith based Roman Catholic literalist standpoint, a stage of violence was set up against those who did not participate in their religious beliefs because the Roman Catholic Church considered themselves superior to those who did not support their viewpoints. Today, this country is suffering from massive cultural divisions.  Those who defend Christianity are out to impose their beliefs on others, and those who do not support Christianity are considered enemies of the truth.  What has been created is an impasse, which can oftentimes be intense and unfriendly.  Many Indian people have foregone the traditional spiritual practices of the past, taken up some other form of religion, or do not practice any form of religion or spirituality at all.  When an individual lives without taking care of the spiritual self, one becomes lost in an abyss of doubt and uncertainty. 

Books describing religious beliefs are filled with religious ideas, symbols and attitudes primarily depicting the beliefs of the times in which they were written. A religious book is meant to be a canvas or a transparency.[xxi]  The one viewing this work is suppose to develop their own perception about the meaning behind the images. The Bible was enforced as the word of God due to the authority of those who were behind its original inception and promotion.  The word for Bible is derived from the Greek word biblia, or “the books,” which is the plural term of biblion, a word taken from the Semitic biblos, meaning “papyrus,” or scroll. Today, the term Bible symbolizes a collection of sacred texts that include: Torah, prophets, wisdom literature, Gospels, and epistles.[xxii] Christians predominantly believe the Bible contains all of God’s messages about creation, His personal nature, desirable behaviors and sin, liberation and salvation. The purpose of the Gospels were to delineate Christ’s life, his teachings and the sharing of good news about Jesus, concerning what he has done for all mankind. 

The past as described in the old testament of the Bible has been laced with stories of destruction in the name of God.  Again, Indian people did not fight over religion or spirituality. The term religionistic has been used when describing organized religion.  Religionistic practices include, but are not limited to; ritual, confinement, persecution, dogma, sins, rights and wrongs. 

Dogma is defined as a set of principles declared as truth without proof. The dogma portrayed as the fear of God has permeated throughout history to control people, and create a hierarchy between those preaching the word and the rest of the population.  Personal interpretations of religious dogma rested on authority regarded as competent to decide and determine law based on the tenets of religion, and cannot be construed as the absolute truth.  Traditionalists often wondered why Christians only participated in spiritual activities once a week.  Traditional Indian forms of spirituality relate to a way of life and are ongoing.

            Bart D. Ehrman in his book entitled Jesus Interrupted, Revealing the Hidden Contradictions of the Bible, stated that many reasons existed to serve as a rationale behind perceived forgeries based on personal interpretations, relating to the Bible and religious dogma.  Forgeries, a term introduced by Ehrman to define biblical discrepancies, relate to the interpretations of biblical texts by individuals who were not qualified to do so, or did so under the pretext of hidden agendas. Those forgeries were put into place to oppose a particular point of view; to make a profit; to oppose an enemy; to defend one’s own belief as divinely inspired; and/or to provide authority for one’s own views.  Keep in mind the fear of God was propagated to create a larger attendance for church services, and to exert control over another’s spiritual beliefs.  Another point to make as described by Marshall in his book The Truth about Jesus and the Lost Gospels, the Gospels in the Bible were not selected because they were better or based on truth.  The Gospels were chosen to serve as a way to establish and secure the authority of male church leaders. [xxiii]  

Ehrman describes many contradictions and falsifications in the Bible. The Old Testament was written over six hundred years by dozens of authors and included 39 books.  The New Testament consisted of 27 books written by 16 or 17 authors over a period of 70 years.  The chance of there being a high level of ambiguity and differing viewpoints is quite high considering the vast amount of time and individuals who contributed to the writing of the Bible.[xxiv] 

If one reads the books of Matthew, Mark and Luke from beginning to end, these books closely resemble one another with similar stories and similar words.  Differences in the messages being portrayed start occurring with the book of John. [xxv] No writings exist dating from Jesus’ actual lifetime or shortly after Jesus’ death.  The original sources that were put together long after his crucifixion no longer exist.  Instead, what survived is renditions entitled the four gospels and other Christian writings, which have gone through many alterations over a long period of time.  It would be a mistake to believe in the complete legitimacy of these written works.

In order for the Bible to be considered the absolute truth there needs to be consistency in the information being portrayed.  It has been considered by many people that the Bible is a historically untrustworthy compilation of legends. During “the Jesus Seminar” a group of scholars stated that only approximately 20 percent of the Jesus sayings were correct. It was also reported that the accounts of Jesus’ life were written many years after the events may have happened. These accounts cannot be considered remotely reliable.[xxvi] 

The Lost Teachings of Jesus by Mark and Elizabeth Prophet and the Gnostic gospels that were discovered in a cave near Nag Hammadi in Egypt could prove to be very interesting reading and may be closer to the truth.  Some of the books in the Bible, like the legends passed down from generation to generation by the Traditionalists, are filled with life lessons that can provide guidance on how to live a life of goodness coupled with how to address problems as they arise.  So much destruction has occurred at the hands of those who believed there was only one source of truth that many do not know where to hang their hat when it comes to seeking a form of spiritual and religious practices.

An on-line survey was conducted by Parade Magazine in October 2009 for a CBS News Sunday Morning program entitled “A Matter of Faith.” The results of this survey were:

·         Twenty-five percent of the respondents reported not being religious.

·         Approximately seven out of ten believe in God.

·         Half rarely attend religious services or they don’t attend at all.

·         Half practice the religion they grew up with.

However, the polls printed in the New York Times article dated April 27, 2009 stated that the number of atheists in the United States is steadily growing.  During the last 50 years instability has been on the rise within many institutions including religious domains.  The hidden agendas of these institutions are being exposed. The accuracy and authenticity of the massive amount of data that is made available today is in question.     Christian dogma falls into this same category, which continues to be fully entrenched within many religious denominations. [xxvii]

Traditionalists practiced a form of spirituality closely associated with a more meaningful relationship with their higher beings. Civilization can be renewed by once again introducing the importance of dreams, visions, and the feeling of connectedness promoted by Traditionalism and the original Christian beliefs, exploring the deeper meaning of the great mysteries.  Fox promoted a pattern, which connected divine love and justice. All humans have within them the ability and promptings to do what is right for others and themselves.  The community way of life in which everyone is treated the same and everyone looks after one another is strongly supported by Fox. Mother Earth and her children have suffered greatly and continue to suffer under patriarchal domination. There continues to be a need to move towards a spiritual vision that prays, celebrates and lives out the reality that there is a God and all humans are his children.  According to Fox, He exists in living and nonliving entities of all shapes and sizes. 

            The worshipping of a false god by seeking material goods, the addiction to alcohol, drugs and entertainment, all tie in with the vast emptiness many people feel.  The missing connection is with the divine and not with those items that quickly lose their worth.  The core of Christianity at its very beginnings was its sense of mystical practice and cosmic awareness before it was taken over by patriarchal domination and the Church.  Mother Earth, the mystical brain in reference to dreams and visions, creativity, wisdom, youth, Traditionalism, and Mother Church are dying, according to Fox. [xxviii]

The boarding and residential school attendees’ hair was cut, hair symbolizes power and other meanings denoted by various tribes and Native American men only cut their hair to show grief or shame. These Indian children were given Christian names and were forced to wear Euro-American clothing, and were also coerced to embrace patriotism for a country who did not respect their existence.  A multitude of Indian people were lost in a world laced with a foreign form of religion coupled with abuse, homesickness and other disturbing feelings without the support and guidance of their parents and other loving caregivers. 

Everyone would benefit from honoring all paths to the divine. The power and control exerted by patriarchal domination and the Church have continued to serve as catalysts for a massive amount of oppression that has been inflicted on Indian people, other people of color, and women.  Validation for many of these harsh actions was derived from false interpretations of a book that needs to be examined for its authenticity, the Bible. Throughout history women have had to pay a high price for these faulty interpretations. Many of the Indian children, who were forced to attend the boarding and residential schools, were often too young to possess the ability to think abstractly.  In other words, they could not formulate concretely the concept of what role the Creator or God occupied in their parents,’ and others’ lives, or even their own.  As a result of various religious sanctions that have been carried out for thousands of years, many people are experiencing feelings of disconnectedness and imbalance because their spiritual needs have not been and are not being met. The perceived superiority of those propagating their religious beliefs as the absolute truth has led to vast spiritual voids.

 

 

 

 



[i] Howard-Brook, W. (2001). The Church Before Christianity.  New York: Orbis Books, 2.

[ii] Corey, G., Corey, M., and Callanan, P. (1998).  Issues and Ethics: In the Helping Professions.  California: Brooks/Cole Publishing Company, 82-83.

[iii] Williston, R., (2003).  Native American Spirituality:A Walk in the Woods.  Ohio:  Rainbow Light and Company. 

[iv] Fox, M. (1988).  The Coming of the Cosmic Christ.  San Francisco:  Harper Collins, 11-34.

[v] Blond, A. (1994). The Private Live of the Roman Emperors. London: Constable and Robinson Ltd., 178 – 185.

[vi] Marshall, D. (2007). The Truth About Jesus and the Lost Gospels.  Oregon: Harvest House Publishers, 6.

[vii] Ibid, 23.

[viii] Ibid, 71.

[ix] Freke, T., and Gandy,P. (1999). The Jesus Mysteries: Was the “Original Jesus” a Pagan God? New York: Three Rivers Press, 6-8.

[x] Prophet, M., and Prophet, E. (1988). The Lost Teachings of Jesus: Missing Texts, Karma, and Reincarnation. New York:  Summit University Press, 173-179.

[xi] Thorn, J. Early Quaker History.  Retrieved on August 9, 2010 from http://thorn.pair.com/earlyq.htm.

[xii] Podles, L. (2008). Sacrilege: Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church.  Maryland: Crossland Press.

[xiii] Buechner, F. (1993).  Wishful Thinking: A Seeker’s ABC.  San Francisco:  Harper Collins Publishers, 27-28.

[xiv] Greeley,A. (2007). Jesus: A Meditation of His Stories and His Relationship with Women. New York: Tom Doherty Associates, LLC, 58-106.

[xv] Marshall, D. (2007). The Truth About Jesus and the Lost Gospels.  Oregon: Harvest House Publishers, 49.

[xvi]Pavlac, B. Timeline for the Witchhunts.  Retrieved on November 23, 2010 from http://departments.kings.edu/womenshistory/witch/

worigin.html

[xvii] Bonfanti,L. (1992). The Witchcraft Hysteria of 1692: Volume 2.  Massachusetts: Old Saltbox Publishing. 

[xviii] Spong,J. (2005). The Sins of the Scriptures: Exposing the Bible’s Text of Hate to Reveal the God of Love. New York: Harper One, 68-100.

[xix] Marshall, D. (2007). The Truth About Jesus and the Lost Gospels.  Oregon: Harvest House Publishers, 124.

[xx]  Williston, R., and Williston,M. (2009). The Ancient Roots of Christianity: A Native American’s Look Through Christianity.  Ohio: Rainbow Light and Co.,178.

[xxi] Buechner, F. (1993).  Wishful Thinkig: A Seeker’s ABC.  San Francisco:  Harper Collins Publishers, 96.

[xxii] Marshall,M. (2007). The Truth About Jesus and the Lost Gospels.  Oregon: Harvest House Publishers, 44-45.

[xxiii] Ibid, 33.

[xxiv] Ehrman, B. (2009). Jesus, Interrupted: Revealing the Hidden Contradictions in the Bible. New York: Harper Collins Publishers, 19-20.

[xxv] Ehrman, B., (2009). Jesus Interrupted: Revealing the Hidden Contraditions in the Bible. New York: Harper Collins Publishers, 6-7.

[xxvi] Keller,T. (2008). The Reason for God: Belief in an Age of Skepticism.  New York: Riverhead Books, 103.

[xxvii] James, R., and Williston, M. (2009). The Ancient Roots of Christianity: A Native American’s Look Through Christianity.  Ohio: Rainbow Light and Co., 30-32. 

[xxviii] Fox, M. (1988).  The Coming of the Cosmic Christ.  San Francisco:  Harper Collins, 11-34.

 

Chapter VI:  The Realization of Manifest Destiny